Get Baked: 9 Best Substitutes for Molasses

Molasses is a terrific addition to lots of baked goodies. It helps make cakes hella moist and can give cookies killer flavor flav. But what do you do when you don’t have any molasses on hand?

If you’re all out of molasses — or if you just don’t like it — you might be on the lookout for a super sweet substitute. Well, look no further! Here’s a list of the nine best substitutes for molasses, plus a guide on how much to use.

9 best molasses substitutes

The nine best replacements for molasses are:

1. Honey
2. Maple syrup
3. Dark corn syrup
4. Sorghum syrup
5. Golden syrup
6. Brown sugar
7. Black treacle
8. Simple syrup
9. Mix-and-match

Here’s the deets on each.

1. Honey

Honey has a similar consistency and texture as molasses. While it doesn’t have the same sultry flavor, there are lots of honey varieties that make a solid substitute. This includes:

• alfalfa honey
• clover honey
• acacia honey
• Manuka honey
• creamed honey
• wildflower honey
• eucalyptus honey
• buckwheat honey
• baker’s special honey
• orange blossom honey

In most cases, you can use a 1:1 replacement ratio. But, you might want to use less honey if you want your recipe to be slightly less sweet.

2. Maple syrup

Maple syrup isn’t just good on pancakes! It also makes for a top-notch swap for molasses. It tastes almost like a mix of malt and caramel, with an even level of sweetness. Like molasses, it comes in a variety of shades.

Just note that maple syrup is a lot thinner than molasses, so you might want to use a 3:4 ration in baked goods. This prevents a batter from thinning out too much. For example, if you’re making a cake, you might want to use 3/4 cup of maple syrup in lieu of 1 cup molasses.

Pro tip: Stick to pure maple syrup if you want to match molasses as much as possible. Artificial maple syrup is mostly corn syrup and artificial flavorings. (Sorry, Mrs. Butterworth.)

3. Dark corn syrup

Like molasses, dark syrup is a liquid sweetener with dark brown color. But unlike molasses, dark corn syrup has a fairly simple taste compared to molasses’ robust flavor profile.

BTW, you can use dark corn syrup as a 1:1 swap for molasses.

4. Sorghum syrup

There’s a good chance sorghum is the item on our list you know the least about. It comes from a cereal grain called (you guessed it!) sorghum. It’s slightly thinner than molasses and has a sweet-yet-slightly-sour taste. A 1:1 substitute works in most situations.

Unless you live in the Southern United States, you might have a hard time finding sorghum syrup in local supermarkets. But have no fear! You can order it online.

5. Golden syrup

Golden syrup (aka light treacle) is uber popular in the United Kingdom. It’s made by evaporating sugar cane until it turns into a thick liquid. Golden syrup has a honey-like color and slightly toasty flavor. Psst. It takes amazing drizzled over oatmeal.

FYI: You can swap 1 cup of molasses for 1 cup of golden syrup.

6. Brown sugar

Brown sugar is a combo of granulated sugar and molasses. This makes it a dope substitute for pure molasses, especially if you use dark brown sugar. Generally, you can replace 1 cup of molasses with 3/4 cup packed brown sugar.

The bad news is that brown sugar is a dry sweetener, which might not work well for a recipe that requires a liquid sweetener. A way around this is adding 1 or 2 tablespoons of water to the brown sugar before adding it to the mix.

7. Black treacle

Black treacle is a thick, dark sugar syrup that contains sugarcane molasses. It’s a lot more popular in the United Kingdom than it is in the United States, but you can def find it online.

Black treacle has a comparable color and taste to molasses, albeit a bit more bitter. Some folks also say it has a slightly burnt taste, but in a food way.

You can use a 1:1 ratio, but might want to scale back if you’re not into its subtle bitter notes.

8. Simple syrup

Simple syrup is made from equal parts sugar and water. All you have to do is boil the sugar in the water until it cooks down into a syrupy consistency. Will simple syrup replace molasses 10/10? TBH, prob not. But if you’re OK with missing out on some maltiness, it’ll do just fine.

PSA: Simple syrup is super sweet. So you might want to start with a 1:2 ratio and see how it tastes. You can always add more if you want to kick it up a notch!

9. Mix-and-match

One of the best parts of cooking is that you get to be creative. So go wild with your molasses substitutes! You can mix-and-match any of the above substitutes. For example:

• 1/2 cup brown sugar and 1/2 cup honey
• 1/2 cup maple syrup and 1/2 cup honey
• 1/2 cup treacle and 1/2 cup golden syrup
• 1/4 cup simple syrup and 1/4 cup brown sugar

How to pick a molasses substitute

Here are some this to think about before picking a molasses substitute.

• Molasses is dark. This is why cookies, breads, and cakes that contain molasses have a distinctive brown color. When you use a sweetener, your end product might come out a lot paler.
• Molasses is moist. Specifically, it’s hygroscopic, which means it’s great at absorbing moisture. This helps give your bakes a dense, almost fudge-like vibe. If you use a substitute, it might change the overall consistency.
• Molasses has a unique flavor. Molasses has a sweet, warm, and almost smoky flavor. When you use a substitute, remember that you might lose some of those distinctive qualities. 
• Molasses is liquid. Liquid sweeteners act differently than dry sweeteners. So keep that in mind if you use a dry substitute like brown sugar.

Molasses nutrition

Here’s what you can expect in 1 tablespoon (20 g) of molasses:

• Calories: 58 kcal
• Fat: 0.02 grams (g)
• Carbs: 14.9 g
• Sugars: 14.9 g
• Calcium: 41 mg
• Potassium: 292 mg
• Magnesium: 48.4 g
• Phosphorus: 6.2 mg

Molasses benefits

Unlike some of the substitutes on our list, molasses offers a few note-worthy health perks.

• Healthy bones. Molasses is a good source of calcium, which plays a major role in bone and tooth health. It also helps with blood clotting, along with healthy muscles, nerve functions, and heart rhythms.
• Heart health. Molasses contains decent amounts of potassium, a vital nutrient that promotes healthy blood pressure and heart health.
• Antioxidants. Does molasses rival super foods like blueberries or kale? No. However, it might have more antioxidants compared to other substitutes on our list.
• Poop probs. In a 2019 study, blackstrap molasses was found to reduce constipation symptoms in kids. Just keep in mind, we need more research to prove the poopy perks.
• Ease arthritis. There’s some anecdotal chatter than blackstrap molasses boasts anti-inflammatory perks that can help relieve joint pain. But there’s no science to back this up.

Takeaway

Molasses is a thick, dark syrup that’s produced during the sugar-making process. If a recipe calls for molasses — but you don’t have any — you can use a substitute. You might even have one of them in your pantry already!